This movie shows the after- effects of partition on the
Sharif class. Within the movie there is the subplot of Amina’s love story.
Amina falls in love with her cousin Kazim but he migrates to Pakistan, leaving
her behind with nothing to hold on to but letters. The crisis however becomes
apparent along the movie when we realize that this isn’t only Amina’s case. We
see the aunt and Amina’s mother discussing how there are no men left in India
and how “itni kawari larkiyan hain har ghar mein” almost as if some misfortune had
fallen each home. The older women are constantly worried about the future
prospects of the younger girls, and we even see them advising one of the
younger girls to sit in “maiyon” soon. The Dadi tells Amina how in their age marriage
was convenient and easy, how they married at an early age before they got
wrinkles. The grandmother’s taunts put emphasis on the bleakness of the marriage
prospects of not only Amina but all the young girls who are left behind. The hopeless
situation is highlighted when we see Amina making a very rational and practical
decision when she accepts Shamshad’s proposal even though she doesn’t love him
and says “mein dosray kou nhi urnay dungi.” However the most poignant moment is when the
family shifts into a smaller haveli and there aren't enough rooms and Amina’s
brother comments “kamray thoray nhi hian, yeh ziada hai.”Although he comments
in a very light joking manner, it highlights the predicament they are facing and the viewer
then questions if there is a larger narrative at play. The subplot seems to
question the fate of the Muslim woman in India. At first we see a lot of inter-
family marriages most likely because they want to maintain the economic and
social status as people are leaving and choices are being narrowed down. Then
the men of the family start to leave as well, leaving a large Muslim feminine
body in India which is useless since now it can’t reproduce and so they can no longer belong
to or participate in the large mother India. Not only can they not reproduce,
but they also don’t participate in the business world or any economic activity “yeh
tou mardon k kaam hain, wohi jaanein.”
The uselessness of the feminine body left behind leads one
to question what kind of future does this class now have? With the Haveli gone and the men leaving, the idea
of the traditional home seems to be lost. The “pinjra” like new house, the restricted
movements when it is too expensive for them to ride a tonga, the failure to
reproduce and with no one to look after the businesses, the Indian Muslims are
constantly being driven into smaller places. So the movie uses the Muslim woman
as an instrument to produce a larger narrative that highlights the hopeless situation of the Indian Muslims and hints at how Pakistan is the only option left for them.
No comments:
Post a Comment